The Theme
And now for something completely different. Each couple is requested to bring a pair of bagged wines. Good wines. Preferably really good wines. The wines should be theoretically really different, but in practice hard to tell which is which. This could mean one really expensive and one really cheap, one old world and one new world, one old but vibrant and one young but complex, same producer but two very different years, same year but two very different producers, etc. Knock yourselves out.
The goal is to fool everyone, but there has to be some possibility to figure it out. We don’t want to have to tell which one is from Hungary and which one is from Turkmenistan.
We’ll start by trying to figure out what they are, completely blind. Then, once we tire of that, the provider will tell us what the two wines are and we’ll try to figure out which is which.
The Results
Thanks to everyone for all the great wines! It was quite an amazing group! A really fun event, with lots of surprises. Below is the list of wines, with my ratings:
Year |
Wine |
From |
Score |
2006 |
Evans Ranch Chardonnay |
Henline |
92 |
1985 |
Christian Brothers Cabernet Sauvignon |
Henline |
88 |
1985 |
Hop Kiln Petite Sirah |
Henline |
90 |
2003 |
Ch. Smith Haut Lafite |
Robinson |
88 |
2003 |
Keenan Meritage |
Robinson |
90 |
2003 |
Woodward Canyon Cabernet Sauvignon |
Robinson |
96 |
1966 |
Ch. Latour |
Alcorn |
93 |
1964 |
Fossi Chianti Classico |
Alcorn |
93 |
1965 |
BV George de la Tour CS |
Alcorn |
95 |
1978 |
Clos de la Roche George Lignier |
Siegel |
99 |
1986 |
Clos de la Roche Hubert Lignier |
Siegel |
87 |
2003 |
Smith Haut Lafite Blanc |
Alcorn |
98 |
2005 |
Mendel Unus (65% Malbec) |
Robinson |
90 |
1999 |
Cote Rotie Brune & Blonde Guigal |
Siegel |
90 |
2004 |
Merus Cabernet Sauvignon |
Siegel |
96 |
2004 |
Ch. Riussec Sauternes |
Henline |
94 |
1997 |
Dolce |
Henline |
89 |
Acquisitions
Recent declines in the stock market improved our luck at the auctions:
1985 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
1986 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
1987 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
1987 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
1989 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
1990 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
1991 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
1993 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
1996 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
1997 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
1998 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
1999 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
2001 |
Berringer Private Reserve |
|
75
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1624 |
1961 |
Bonnes Mares – Drouhin-Laroze |
|
550
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1262 |
2001 |
Ch d’Yquem |
tenth |
300
|
|
CellaRaiders |
2001 |
Ch d’Yquem |
tenth |
300
|
|
CellaRaiders |
1959 |
Ch Lafite |
|
1450
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1807 |
1961 |
Ch Lynch Bages |
|
600
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1008 |
2003 |
Ch Montrose |
magnum |
600
|
|
CellaRaiders |
1961 |
Ch Mouton Rothschild |
|
1700
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1011 |
1985 |
Grand Echezeaux – DRC |
|
900
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1111 |
1949 |
Mazis Chambertin – Seguin-Manuel |
|
500
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 2048 |
1961 |
Musigny – Hudelot |
|
550
|
|
Bonhams 6/08 Lot 1262 |
|
|
|
$8425
|
|
|
There are several 100 point wines up there. I leave it to you to figure out which they are!
Upcoming Events
Treasurer’s Report
Previous Balance |
3548 |
Dues Payable (less cost of dinner for 2) |
4584 |
Purchases |
-8425 |
Dinner (for 8) |
-1662 |
Balance |
-1955 |
Please bring your dues of $1000 per couple to the event. |